bulletin > 22 professor george hampel supports pad bill

Bulletin 22: Professor George Hampel Supports PAD Bill

   

1th August 2008

 

Professor The Hon. George Hampel AM QC, former Justice of the Supreme Court, recently said of the Physician Assisted Dying (PAD) Bill, which itself was written under guidance of Professor David Kelly, former Chairman of the Victorian Law Reform Commission:


The proposed legislation would enable doctors to help people in a professional and open, but controlled way, to end their misery.  The safeguards provided are impressive and adequate to protect the sufferer, his or her family, the doctors involved and the community.


It is, I think, in the community’s interests that, while life is respected, it can be ended by those who suffer intolerably and wish to exercise their free choice.  It is important that this right can be exercised in a controlled way, without subterfuge and misuse.”


In fact, the Bill contains more safeguards than the Northern Territory Rights of the Terminally Ill Act 1995 and the Oregon Death With Dignity Act 1997, combined:

 

Safeguards

  

NT ROTI Act

  

Oregon DWDA

  

Victorian PAD Bill

Injection permitted

 

Yes

 

No

 

No

Residency

 

None

 

Medium

 

Strong

Signed requests

 

Medium (one)

 

Medium (one)

 

High (two)

Inheritance

 

None for signatories

 

None for signatories

 

None for anyone who assists in any way

Parliamentary oversight

 

Annual report tabled in Parliament

 

DHS produces annual report

 

Joint, all-party Parliamentary committee scrutinises annual report

 

Professor David Kelly says, “Simplicity and transparency are not always features of legislation. The Bill has been written in such a way as to ensure that it can be understood by as wide an audience as possible—an overriding principle.  Some Members of Parliament may be uncomfortable at first, simply because they are not used to it.”

 

Professor The Hon.
George Hampel AM QC

 

Site Map | Search | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Disclaimer | © 2001-2009 Dying With Dignity Victoria, Inc. All rights reserved worldwide.