Mum, Barbara (“Barb”) Godwin, was diagnosed with vascular dementia in late 2021, approximately 10 months after she started having small transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) due to a blocked carotid artery. These TIAs started around four months after she had triple bypass surgery at Epworth Hospital at the age of 89. (This is a separate story in itself.)
Until her diagnosis, mum was living independently in a unit in Hawthorn with the dedicated support of my brother who lived five minutes away. In addition to high blood pressure, she lived with chronic back pain which she had always managed through regular physiotherapy sessions and exercise. After a series of emergency hospitalisations following falls relating to cognitive confusion (e.g., putting out the bins in the middle of the night), we were told that mum could no longer live independently at home, and we moved her into an aged care home in October 2021 - a home that is generally regarded as one of the finest available.
At the aged care home, despite mum having a clear Advance Care Directive (ACD) outlining her wishes should she be diagnosed with dementia, my siblings and I had to advocate for every right contained within this document. We had to repeatedly advocate for her wish not to be hospitalised (e.g., when she broke her shoulder in a fall, or when there was discussion of amputating her toes), not to receive medications aimed at prolonging her life (e.g., blood pressure medication), and to cease ineffective antibiotics when the circulation to her right toes became so poor that open wounds caused an intractable staph infection that overwhelmed her body. We have also had to fight for her pain to be recognised and appropriately treated.
I have two siblings. Abby is a former nurse. Andrew is a lawyer and academic. I am a musician and researcher. As a team, we have been united and dedicated advocates and supports for our mum, sustaining a constant presence in her life. We are also united in our understanding of our mother’s views on the ethical balance between preserving life and relieving suffering, and her belief in the right to a dignified, graceful, compassionate and humane end of life.
The final 2.5 years of mum’s nearly 4.5 years at the aged care home were terribly difficult. As mum’s dementia advanced, so too her “challenging behaviours” increased. We watched our mum - a dedicated, passionate physiotherapist who spent her working life supporting children with intellectual disabilities - become angry, aggressive and lost within her dementia. She walked relentlessly, at all times of the day and night, but particularly night. She would not want to wake in the morning - after walking all night - and would become aggressive with carers when they tried to shower and toilet her. This is the story of dementia, an experience shared by so many sufferers and their families. It was aggravated by the aged care home’s seeming inability to accommodate the individual needs of residents with dementia, and the gaps in specialist dementia knowledge within the care and nursing team.
We believed that mum’s “challenging behaviour” was driven, in part, by pain. We recognised this around two years before her death when the Nursing Unit Manager said to me “At least she is not in pain.” The absurdity of the statement was a clarion call to action for my sister and myself. We knew that there was no possibility that mum was not in pain. She had suffered from chronic back pain for the past 15 years of her life, and had multiple spinal surgeries. Prior to developing dementia, mum had an incredibly high tolerance for pain and would walk and move to manage her pain. Now, in her state of advanced dementia, her back pain was undoubtedly still present, as too ongoing pain related to her untreated broken right shoulder. Not to mention other forms of psychic (psychological, spiritual) pain that we believed she was experiencing.
Abby and I represented mum’s pain to the aged care home, but the nursing staff resisted recognising and treating it, arguing that pain medication would increase her risk of falls. We eventually had to call upon the surgeon who performed her back surgeries, her long time physiotherapist and her consulting geriatrician to support our request for appropriate pain medication. Our advocacy efforts resulted in four-hourly Panadol and additional medication PRN. For clarity, PRN (“pro re nata” or “as needed”) refers to medications, like pain relief, that are prescribed to be taken on an as-needed basis, with the frequency and dosage dependent on an individual’s needs. For a person with advanced dementia, the “as needed” is determined by nursing staff, with input from care staff. This meant that mum received PRN pain relief only when a member of her care team was able to recognise that she was in pain and then advocate for pain relief. For mum, having access to meaningful pain relief at the discretion of staff (carers and nurses) proved problematic as we discovered many were either unable to recognise her pain, or had personal or professional feelings about the use of pain medication.
After a very difficult period of time during which Abby and I advocated persistently in the face of what we believed to be clear signs of mum’s pain, the aged care home finally acknowledged that they had failed to adequately recognise and manage mum’s pain. We were told that mum’s case had catalysed efforts to educate staff in the recognition of pain. Despite this, questions about whether mum’s pain was being adequately relieved would persist until the end of her life.
Jumping forward, mum died on Sunday 1 March 2026. She died with open, infected wounds on her toes, a black bedsore on her heel that was the size of the base of a coffee cup, and red tracks running up her legs evidencing the overwhelming staph infection. On her last day, she was burning up from this infection.
We were fortunate to have the support of Mum’s geriatrician, who had made sure that the aged care home had end-of-life medication on hand. Yet, this medication was not administered until the day prior to her death. And the sub-cutaneous morphine was only started as a result of our advocacy and presence.
Referencing our family text messages, WhatsApp chats and emails, the period from the end of January to mum’s death documents what I refer to as her “death by bureaucratic spreadsheet”. It also documents the profound distress that my siblings and I experienced as we watched our mother die.
These messages document communication from the aged care home about the shocking ulcers on mum’s feet and the challenges in managing her pain during daily wound dressings. They document dietitian concerns about her progressive weight loss. They document conversations about specialist recommendations to x-ray mum’s toes to investigate whether to have her toes amputated, despite the intractable infection that would not be cured by amputation. They document our decision to respect mum’s wishes contained in her ACD and cease the use of antibiotics.
Over the month prior to her death, we watched mum’s deterioration with increasing distress. Respecting her wish for “maximum palliation”, as documented in her ACD, we continued to advocate for appropriate pain medication. The “comfort care” that the home argued it was providing was contradicted by our observations of mum’s pain and distress.
Just under a month prior to her death (6 February) we asked the aged care home to seek support from a regional palliative care service. The aged care home agreed to submit an application, but advised that, as mum was still eating and drinking, awake and responding, the application would be rejected. We were told that, until such time as mum stops eating, drinking and responding, she would not be considered eligible for palliation. My sister, as Medical Power of Attorney, was told that ceasing antibiotics and other treatments, and continuing to advocate for appropriate pain medication represented the limit of her power at this time.
On 11 February we were notified that mum was no longer able to feed herself. On 14 February, I observed that a carer who was feeding mum did not notice that she was storing food in her mouth and not swallowing. On 17 February we were advised that the application to the regional palliative care services had been rejected as mum was “not eligible”. On 18 February, Abby rang the palliative care service and described mum’s condition, and mum was immediately added to the list. On 20 February, the palliative care service visited mum, spoke to us, and assured us that the aged care home would manage mum’s end of life. We were told that there was still “some time” before she reached this stage, and that mum was not considered to be in pain as she was not “screaming in pain.” She told us to “dial down” our anxiety and to stop representing our concerns to the nursing staff.
Abby and my text messages to each other following this meeting communicate the emotional and psychological distress we were experiencing:
■ Lou: I didn’t choose to watch her die in this way, so I WON’T watch her death any longer. I am cancelling my subscription. Let’s just stop thinking about her and feeling like we have a role in this drama series. Let’s just look after ourselves, try to enjoy life, and await the inevitable. [heart emoji]
■ Ab: “I cancel my subscription”. Mum has never screamed in pain. All I can picture at the moment is that necrosis getting worse so eventually she’s lying in bed with a black stump. It’s still comfort care.
■ Lou: I know Ab. It’s awful. I agree completely.
During the week prior to her death, on three occasions, I observed mum storing food in her cheek while being fed by carers. I also witnessed her clear expressions of pain, distress and discomfort. As I wrote in a message to my siblings on 27 February:
Hi you two. I have been reflecting on mum’s ongoing experience of dying. I am not sure that our issue is with VAD. I think our issue is with the way people with dementia are forced to die due to the legal framework that aged care facilities work within. The absence of compassionate, person-centered, truly individualised medical care (including recognising and appropriately medicating for pain, anxiety and distress) that is provided. People are infantilised at the end of their lives. They are treated as if they can no longer experience any form of spiritual or existential distress due to the dementia. They are treated as if they don’t have pain: or the pain is only recognised when it manifests in the most crude and simplistic expressions of pain. I am watching mum lying in bed. Her face is not peaceful. Every couple of seconds she arches her back, and pulls her knees up, and her arms and hands tense up. Is this not distress? Is this not pain? Why does she have to experience it? Why are we the only ones who bear witness and recognise it?
I am not suggesting that the home is doing anything wrong. Or that there is anything we should do. Or, in fact, that VAD is the solution right now. I am suggesting that we should promise to try to do something about working toward better, more compassionate, less punishing deaths for people who are dying from dementia.
I have kept the following notes of my memories of mum’s last days:
Saturday 28 Feb:
I went up to the home and sat with mum while a carer attempted to give her some thickened liquid. Mum was barely conscious, and feverish. As I watched, I noticed that she was not swallowing, and drew the carer’s attention to this. I decided to ring my siblings, and went into the foyer (where there is mobile reception). I was approached by the nurse in charge who said to me “I just want to check that you are aware of where your mum is at.” I said, “We all know that she is dying. But this is a relief for us. She is ready.” The nurse then said, “She has been dying for a long time. You know I have been caring for your mum for a long time now. I know she has been ready to die for a long time. It’s just that we have to operate within norms.”
My siblings arrived, and Abby attempted to give mum some fluid. She affirmed that mum was not swallowing, and went to find the nurse in charge to ask him to come to mum’s room. The nurse attempted to give mum some thickened liquid, and confirmed she was not swallowing. He said that, as we were all present, he could get the paperwork for us to sign so that they could commence the end-of-life (EOL) medication. We all agreed. The paperwork was signed at around 2pm, and the nurses started the medication. We sat with mum. We were all very upset by the situation. We were disturbed that nobody had noticed mum was no longer swallowing - despite my having reported the incidents of her not swallowing when I had visited during the week prior - and upset that we had to initiate the process of determining that she was ready for EOL meds.
Sunday 1 March:
I went up to the home and sat with mum for some time that morning. She was no longer conscious, and was burning up with fever. At one point, a carer came in and swabbed her mouth. Other than that, no-one came near us. Around 10:45am, Andrew and Abby arrived to say goodbye. We spent some time with her. Again, no-one came past. I went home, but returned at about 4pm with my two daughters. By this point, mum’s fever was extremely high. She was completely alone. No-one came near us until we left. At around 8:47pm, a nurse called to say that mum had died.
Reflections on mum’s end of life
I have reflected deeply on mum’s final week, but particularly her final two days, and recall feeling profound grief, isolation and fear. This is exacerbated by my memory, from many years ago, of sitting with a friend who was dying at The Austin Hospital. As his carers and I sat at his bedside, a palliative care nurse would enter the room every few minutes. She would come and stand beside us, and offer affirmation through her presence and words. “This is perfect.” “This is exactly as it should be.” “Jack is doing so well.” “You are doing so well.” It was a beautiful experience in which we all felt supported and safe.
Mum’s death was the polar opposite. We were unsupported, and felt scared and isolated. The home provided minimal support to us, other than the gentle words of one carer who happened to enter the room to check mum’s mouth. No other nurse came near mum during the time we spent with her.
In the context of the trauma of the weeks leading up to her death, it was heartbreaking and inhumane. I sat while my mother lay on her bed, burning up with fever from incurable ulcers, with humane and compassionate relief ONLY provided because I was with her on the Saturday morning and able to call my brother and sister. I often wonder how much worse her death would have been without our presence. If she was alone. If her family had, as so many do, decided that they could no longer maintain an active involvement in their loved one’s life.
What I can’t comprehend is how a human can be forced to die in the manner of our mother’s death? In 2026, people with dementia die by bureaucratic spreadsheet. Since our father died with vascular dementia in 2017, the capacity in the system that allowed him to die in a gentle and timely manner has been removed. Instead, our mother was forced to experience a traumatic, painful and extended death. Against the backdrop of the advancements and knowledge that we have at our disposal in 2026, mum’s suffering was profound. It was devastating and cruel.
In sharing mum’s story, Abby, Andrew and I hope to encourage conversations about end of life for people with dementia. The perspectives we share in this story are deeply subjective and shaped by our individual and shared efforts to make sense of our mother’s death. This is an ongoing project for each of us. Given that such a complex subject requires a nuanced lens that is flexible and open to change, we can’t promise that our thinking won’t shift over time.
Although he has not undertaken any in-depth research, Andrew strongly believes, both from a personal and legal perspective, that if people with dementia demonstrate signs of severe pain but are unable to articulate the extent of their pain, a legal presumption should arise that they are experiencing the most severe pain and it should become possible to treat them accordingly. This is subject (of course) to the compassionate and experienced input from those who are in the best position to determine what would be appropriate treatment for the person, including their doctors and their loved ones, and to moderate the treatment in the circumstances. Indeed, this is how things used to work, when the world was a more humane place, when doctors could exercise their professional and ethical discretion, and when the community was not subject to bureaucratic spreadsheets and idealistic (but completely naïve) legislative frameworks.
Andrew believes that the right to die with dignity and with minimal possible pain and suffering is one of the most fundamental rights that is not currently established as a universal human right but should nonetheless be recognised as such. This is a right that is often beyond the control of people with dementia to assert or exercise and we need to address this.
For me, I believe we need more compassion and humanity in the way we think about the pain and suffering experienced by people with advanced dementia. Particularly people living in aged care facilities where their identity and lived experience too often disappears beneath their diagnosis and care tasks[i].
So far, my reading of research literature resonates closely with mum’s experience. The interrelationship between pain and dementia-associated behaviour makes assessment challenging[ii], which means that pain continues to be under-diagnosed and under-treated[iii]. Pain-related behaviours are often obscured by the dementia diagnosis and misread as behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia (i.e., aggression, agitation, non-compliance, disinhibition). Best practice symptom management is challenged by the need for better care staff training and support, particularly in relation to improved pain assessment, administering medication and managing end of life symptoms[iv] [v]. And, experiences of end of life are compromised by the fact that palliative care services, aged care and dementia care services are fragmented and disjointed[vi].
Alongside the systemic changes that are clearly needed, I believe we need to adopt a wider, more nuanced, multi-dimensional understanding of pain for people with advanced dementia. Brant (2017) names this as ‘holistic total pain’, defined as encompassing physical, psychological, social, spiritual, existential and cultural aspects[vii]. For all of us, pain is a deeply personal and subjective experience. We can only understand another’s pain in the context of all the factors that are unique to each of us as humans, including demographic, genetic, psychosocial factors and, importantly, lived experience[viii].
As I reflect on what might have improved both the quality of our mother's life as her dementia advanced and the quality of her death, I believe that knowing her, her life story and wishes is the starting point. The Advance Care Directive should have served this purpose, but it didn't. Perhaps emergent dementia-specific narrative tools, such as values statements, pain narratives or dementia-specific directives, might offer living, holistic documents that can help us to know the person when they are no longer able to communicate their own story.
[i] Berendonk, C., Blix, B. H., Hoben, M., Clandinin, D. J., Roach, P. M., Compton, R. M., ... & Caine, V. (2020). A narrative care approach for persons living with dementia in institutional care settings. International Journal of Older People Nursing, 15(1), e12278.
[ii] Jonsdottir, P. T., & Gunnarsson, R. E. C. (2021). Understanding nurses’ knowledge and attitudes toward pain assessment in dementia: A literature review. Pain Management Nursing, 22(3), 281-292.
[iii] Centmayer, R., Leiske, M., & Lahmann, N. A. (2024). Pain prevalence and pain management in nursing home residents with cognitive impairment. Results from five multicenter cross-sectional surveys in Germany between 2014 and 2018. Pain Management Nursing, 25(5), 487-493.
[iv] Tolman, S., & Dening, K. H. (2018). A relationship-centred approach to managing pain in dementia. Nursing Older People, 30(1).
[v] Gamage, M. W. K., Todorovic, M., Moyle, W., & Pu, L. (2023). Cultural influence on nurses’ pain observations related to dementia: an integrative review. Pain Management Nursing, 24(4), 406-426.
[vi] Drummond, M., & Johnston, B. (2024). Symptom management for people with advanced dementia who are receiving end of life care. Current Opinion in Supportive and Palliative Care, 18(4), 219-223.
[vii] Brant, J. M. (2017). Holistic total pain management in palliative care: cultural and global considerations. Palliative Med Hosp Care Open J, 1, S32-S38.
[viii] Fillingim, R. B. (2017). Individual differences in pain: understanding the mosaic that makes pain personal. Pain, 158, S11-S18, p.2.

